Pracandy

Features

How 2001: A Space Odyssey ended up in Apple v. Samsung

At a glance

Samsung cited Kubrick's 1968 tablets against Apple's iPad design patent, and the court never let the jury see them.

By Swotboysandy1 min read

Ask AI about this story

A Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet
Image: Photo: Mro, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
On this page

In 2011 Apple sued Samsung in California, claiming the Galaxy phones and tablets copied the iPhone and iPad. One of Samsung's defences came from a film made more than forty years earlier.

The filing

On 24 August 2011, opposing Apple's request to block sales of the Galaxy Tab 10.1, Samsung attached a still from Stanley Kubrick's 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968). In it, two astronauts eat while using flat personal tablets. Samsung's argument was that this shape was already known, so Apple's design patent on the iPad, known as D'889, should not cover it.

What the court did with it

The film never reached the jury. Magistrate Judge Paul Grewal excluded it, and in August 2012 Judge Lucy Koh upheld that decision, noting that Samsung had not disclosed in time that it meant to use the film to argue the patent was invalid.

The verdict

  • The jury awarded Apple about $1.05 billion for infringement of other patents.
  • On the iPad design patent, the jury sided with Samsung: it found the Galaxy Tab 10.1 did not infringe D'889.
  • The damages were later reduced and retried over several years.

So Kubrick's tablets made headlines but played no part in the jury's decision. Samsung's tablet was cleared on the design question without them.

  • Half closed laptop (Unsplash)Image: Photo: Luca Bravo lucabravo, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons

    Features3 min read

    What Is llms.txt, and Does a Small Site Need One?

    What is llms.txt? It is a simple Markdown file placed at your website's root directory that lists specific URLs and brief descriptions, acting as a table…

  • Tack room setup Synths hungImage: Photo: John Athayde, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

    Features2 min read

    How to harden your server against common web exploits

    Run a reverse proxy like Caddy to terminate TLS and filter traffic before it reaches your application.

  • Rob Schnautz's remote officeImage: Photo: Bob the Wikipedian, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

    Features2 min read

    The Best Tools for Solo Founders in 2027

    The best tools for solo founders in 2027 are not defined by hype but by how well they fit a lean, single-operator workflow.